Some Observations On Guitar Necks & Frets

SOME OBSERVATIONS ON GUITAR NECKS & FRETS

By Anthony Lintner

The overall correct process of placing frets in a guitar fingerboard ("fretting"), is far less straight forward than most people believe. A perfect job, for perfect playability, requires some careful preparation. I'll first describe how I "fret" a flat fingerboard without binding. Before I begin, I'd like to mention that flat boards are standard on classicals, and that they're acceptable, if not desirable, on many steel strung instruments as well. A flat board is far easier to "true" and to "fret," and it's probably superior for the player as well.

The primary tools are: fret hammer, wire nippers, fretting stick, sanding black, fret saw, and fretting block. These are:

1. Fret Hammer: I use a light brass hammer with the face very slightly rounded (arched), and the edges tapered. (A small ball-peen hammer can also be used if the face is ground very slightly convex).

2. Wire Nippers: purchaseable pre-ground for fret work, or have the face of the jaws ground so that the nipper cuts flush with a flat surface.

3. Fretting Stick: either bought or home-made, and used to mark off fret positions. (Your fret placement can be no more accurate than your fretting stick).

4. Sanding Block: (for truing fingerboards, etc.) I prefer 2 hardwood blocks, a narrower block for initial rough work, size 1-1/4"x 1-1/2"x 7-3/8", and a larger block for final accurate flattening (truing) of the board, size W=2-5/8", H=1-5/8", L=7- 3/8". While leather or cork padding is a must if you're using a block to sand tops, etc., use a plain, wooden block for the final sanding on the fingerboard. Simply cut out to size, and prefold assorted grades of sandpaper (garnet works great) to fit snugly around the flat sanding bottom of the block, and hold the paper tightly against the sides of the block as you sand.

necks&fretsimg3

5. Fret Saw: As I haven't tried any fret saws I really like, I adjust my saws as follows. I choose a saw with the finest teeth that will cut a kerf no less the .002" narrower than the fret tang. My frets have tangs that are .031" wide at the bead. Therefore, I want a saw that wiII cut a .030" kerf. (Measure with an inexpensive leaf gauge.) A slightly oversize saw can be made to cut a .030" kerf by using a vise with smooth, straight jaws to squeeze the set in the saw teeth. First place a leaf gauge of .030" in the jaws of the vise. With the vise jaws tightened, measure the degree of turn in the vise handle precisely, and place the saw blade in the vise and compress the teeth to .030". (if there is springback in the teeth, compress them to .029", etc.) Finally, I also like to open the back or "spine" on a dovetail saw (fret saw), and reverse the blade so that it cuts on the pull stroke. I then squeeze the back tight over the blade in a vise, hammer it, and rivet it. Additionally, if the saw blade is longer than 7-1/4", I cut it shorter with a Dremel cutting wheel.

6. Fretting Block: I use a fretting block because I cut the fret slots after the fingerboard is glued on. This hardwood block, W=2", H=1", L=3/8", has a rubber (inner tube), non-skid, flat bottom, which when placed on a freshly sanded fingerboard will not slip and can be used to accurately guide the fret saw and to hold it at 90 degrees. I also glue an ebony strip on the longer, sawing edge of the fretting block for increased durability.

Top

Dive To Bottom

After the slotless fingerboard is absolutely flat, I string up the classical guitar, and leave it tuned for a day. After that time, the neck should have the proper "relief", meaning that the top of the fingerboard should be very slightly concave or dipped, with the dip being centered between where the 5th and 6th frets would be. This dip should be between 1/64" and 1/32" deep, with the greater depth on the bass side. This dip, or concavity, begins at the nut, and should taper out to flat around, or slightly beyond the 12th fret. This relief is necessary because greater string clearance is needed closest to the nut, because a longer string vibrates over a wider distance. In other words, the fingerboard should "fall away" from the string more precipitously nearer the nut, and gradually less so as the string is shortened in the higher fingerboard positions. If the proper relief isn't present, remove the strings and sand very carefully, using the blocks either lengthwise (parallel) or edgewise (perpendicular) to the fingerboard as necessary. All final sanding should be done with paper no coarser than 220 to 280.

Now mark out the slots, by first drawing a center line down the middle of the board. Then draw parallel lines to this center line as close to both edges of the board as possible. Then, with the fretting stick, mark off the fret positions with a fine pen or pencil. Finally, using a plastic or metal square aligned up against either of the two parallel lines, scribe the fret position marks.

Using the rubber-bottomed fretting block with its 90 degree edge, I make my starting cuts with the fret saw. A still finer toothed and narrower saw than the fret saw might be used to make the initial starting cuts in the fingerboard easier. After approximately 1/32" deep starting cuts have been made at all the fret positions using the .030" fret saw, clamp two 1/8" strips of hardwood on both sides of the fret saw with 2 smallest size c-clamps. Allow just enough of the teeth and blade to protrude, so that the saw would cut a slot the exact depth of the fret tang. Place a protective piece of sheet aluminum on the guitar top, with masking tape on the bottom of the metal, so that the aluminum won't discolor an unfinished top. It is also best to saw the slots twice, from both directions,to make an extra clean slot. Finally, don't forget to always experiment with scrap wood to test tolerances. (If you're fretting a rosewood board you should use a .029" saw.)

necks&fretsimg1

Uncoil the fretwire and cut it into 1 foot lengths. (I always use hard fretwire for longer playing life, even though hard wire is more difficult to work with.) I then carefully straighten these foot sections as much as possible, using smooth jawed pliers if needed. Finally, I cut the frets about 1/2" longer than each fret slot, and I arrange them in order on a work table. Before I begin hammering in the frets, I very gently pass over the top of each fret slot with a fine, triangular file. I do this in order to taper the sharp edges at the entry point of each slot. This not only permits easier entrance for the frets, but also prevents chipping of the board, if the frets need to be pulled out for any reason. I then vacuum out the slots and begin.

I use liquid hide glue of medium-thin consistency. (Don't use hot glue or other glues.) Using a glue injector, I run glue inside 2 or 3 consectutive slots at a time. I quickly work this glue into each slot with an extra-fine spatula, and I wipe off any excess glue. I then place a fret over a slot and hammer lightly at each end of the fret until the fret is partially seated. I then tap across the fret wire with the hammer, concentrating the taps on the ends of the frets, and beginning with light taps and ending in heavier taps as the fret becomes better seated. When the frets are well seated, tap the protruding fret ends down a very little bit, so that only the slightest bend is visible when sighting along the fret. Wipe off the glue ooze and continue, etc.

When all the frets are done, a damp cotton cloth, or piece of towel will remove all glue residue off the fingerboard. It is unnecessary, but permissable to clamp a straight piece of wood to the fingerboard to hold down all of the frets as the glue dries. When dry, clip off the overhanging fret ends and file the sharp edges smooth by running a fine flat file along the edge of the board. The ends of the frets should also be rounded off, and a small, very fine square or rectangular file used to slightly round off the edge or side of each fret at their ends. This will remove any remaining sharpness at the fret ends that could irritate a player's hand. Done properly, the frets will not need filing on the crowns, except if they are considered too high, and if flatter, lower frets are desired. (Sometimes, frets are imperfectly made at the factory, and will need filing for that reason.)

Lowering of the fret crowns is done with a straight, flat, wide file, ideally, about 8" long. Filing, in parallel strokes to the neck, must be done in such a way that the neck relief is not disturbed. On the other hand, if the relief is incorrect, now is the time to make a slight correction.

If the crowns have been lowered, they should be rounded off, since a square-topped fret will not play cleanly or absolutely true. Roundig off, is either done with individual fine files (where the fingerboard should be taped off to prevent file mars), or, more easily, special fret rounding files can be used. When using the fret files, clean off metal chips, and file mostly in one direction, in order to minimize marring the frets.

When filing is completed, polish the frets with fine silicon carbide paper, i.e., 280, 320, 400 and 600 grades respectively. Finally, polish the frets with 000 and 0000 steel wools. When done, vacuum off all dust and steel wool fragments, and clean off the fingerboard with a cotton swab and lacquer thinner. Before stringing and playing the guitar, lubricate the fingerboard with a 50/50 mixture of turpentine and linseed oil, wiping off the excess.

Comments: if the fret slots are too tight (narrow) for the fret tangs, the frets will have a cumulative "wedging" effect on the fingerboard, and force the neck backward, cancelling out the neck relief. If the slots are too wide, the frets won't seat properly, and the slots will compress when the guitar is strung up, producing a "kerf" effect, resulting in excessive neck relief.

necks&fretsimg2

The fretting methods just mentioned, can be used when replacing fingerboards on classical or on steel-string guitars with non-adjustable necks, or when building such instruments. However, when refretting such guitars, approximate relief adjustments must be determined in advance, before the old frets are pulled out. The degree of flexion in a non-adjustable neck (before the old frets are removed), determines how flat or relieved the fingerboard should be after the frets are removed. If in doubt, always true a neck fiat, and file some of the relief into the frets later, if absolutely needed, which shouldn't be too often.

In the case of adjustable steel string or electric necks, tighten the adjusting nut several turns before truing the fingerboard straight. In this manner, the truss rod can be loosened to allow for adjustments in both directions. Additionally, this prevents an internally loose or sloppy neck, which could happen if the rod required complete loosening for proper action after the guitar had been strung up. Such a neck might rattle, and "sustain" could be reduced.

Additional notes: curved fingerboards, to be arched properly, should be thought of as being a "slice" off a tapered cone, with the cone's bass being toward the guitar body. In other words, the curvature of the arch at the top of the fingerboard decreases the higher one goes up the neck away from the nut. This also means, that a straight edge run parallel to each string, and placed where each string would naturally lie, must be flush and level along the entire length of the fingerboard. When "fretting" an arched fingerboard, a fretting block with a rubber-lined, concave bottom can be used.

Fingerboards with bindings require little ledges cut out at the ends of the frets so that the fret crowns can pass over the neck binding. I don't like binding on principle, and have compromised by laminating rock maple binding to ebony fingerboards and fretted the boards as usual. This method is both decorative and functional, and results in easier and better fret placement. It permits the fret to run the entire width of the neck, thus preventing snagging of the 1st string on the fret ends. It is also an attractive, clean design for a guitar neck.

Anthony developed an early interest in guitar as a boy growing up in Argentina and Chile. In the mid-sixties he became seriously involved in playing, repairing and constructing guitars, and he has been professionally repairing and building for 12 years in Pittsburgh, PA. In his own words he is a "fanatic when it concerns the smooth and perfect action of an instrument."

Text From The Luthiers' Mercantile Catalog - 1993

Previous | Next | Top | Construction Tutorials | Home

- 9.12 -