French Polishing

FRENCH POLISHING

INTRODUCTION

Up until the last ten or fifteen years French polishing had been a dying art. As woodworking, furniture and cabinetmaking, gained footholds in the lives of the expanding class of "do- it-yourselfers," many of the forgotten methods of craftsmanship, including French polishing, found expression in the work of more and more woodworkers.

Instrument makers who have tried the French polish method of finish claim improved sound in their instruments, although admittedly, at the expense of decreased wear resistance. To achieve the bewildering balance of aesthetics and utility a compromise is required. Those luthiers that use French polish, commonly use this method for the soundboards only, and spray lacquer or varnish the back, sides and neck.

There are disadvantages to the use of French polish, but whatever drawbacks there are, the claims of many can't be ignored: when applied to guitar tops it is unrivaled in the way it pleases the ear and in the way it appeals to the eye.

ADVANTAGES:

1. A good French polish is unsurpassed for beauty, depth of color, and richness.
2. French polish is highly resistant to cold-checking.
3. French polish (F.P. after this) gives the brightest sounding finish for acoustic guitars.
4. F.P. is very easy to replace and to repair in worn areas.

Carlos Pina Rodriguez - 1999

Zoom

DISADVANTAGES:

1. F.P. is susceptible to damage by prolonged contact with water or alcohol (common solvents for those of us who drink or wash). Water will leave a white mark after a few hours.
2. F.P. is not as wear resistant as varnish or lacquer, the two main instrument finishes. A player with sweaty hands tends to wear away F.P.
3. F.P. scratches white, thus scratches show. On the other hand they can usually be repaired fairly easily.

Common practice is to French Polish the tops of nylon string guitars (classic and flamenco) and spray lacquer the balance of the instrument. Steel string instruments are more often completely lacquered with the finish kept thin on top.

Top

Dive To Bottom

THE PROCESS IN GENERAL

Porous woods must be filled: In F.P. it can be done either with pastewood filler, our transparent filler (FT) or by the old "Pumice in the F.P." method. Instructions for the use of pastewood filler will not be included here except to say that a good wash coat of shellac should precede the use of pastewood filler to help color the pores dark, not to stain the wood. After filling and touching up the surface lightly with #400 sandpaper to smooth it and even the color, F.P. can begin. The original wash coat can be put on either with a brush or with a well soaked pad. The wash coat should dry in a few hours. The filler (if not using our FT) needs 48 hours if possible, or even more. 24 hours in a warm room is absolute minimum.

Another way to fill porous wood is to begin the wash coat with a well soaked pad. Continue laying on wash coats of F.P. until a slight surface begins to appear - a shine. Then sprinkle finely ground pumice powder over the surface a little at a time and with circular motions begin to work it, along with F.P., into the pores. In skilled hands this is a quick and effectIve way to fill porous wood.

From this point on the balance of the filling can be done by the F.P. itself since, unlike other finishes, it has the characteristic of filling small holes.

The finish is now ready for bodying. That is to say, building up a layer of F.P. of adequate thickness. This is done by going over the surface 100's or 1000's of times in circular or "figure 8" motions, leaving endless coats of minute thickness which eventually add together to make a full depth surface.

Where adequate depth has been achieved, a difficult part remains - spiriting off the surface. In this process, a nearly dry pad is used with considerable pressure and speed (often in straight lines slightly moistened with thinner) to remove any oil from the finish that was used during the bodying. The intent is to glaze the surface and produce a shine.

So the steps are as follows:

1. Seal with a wash coat
2. Fill porous woods
3. Body the finish
4. Spirit off the surface

THE PROCESS IN DETAIL

The Pad, "Fad" or "Rubber": The pad should be made from a fine, soft, lint-free material, like linen, unbleached cotton, etc. Make sure you wash this "trace cloth" several times to remove any hint of lint. Do not bleach it, as this weakens fibers. For guitars, a piece about 4"-8" square is O.K. When one area wears out, move the stuffing material over a bit.

The best stuffing material seems to be cotton waste. The cotton waste we supply is superior to other materials in that it doesn't tend to compress and harden during the polishing (as does cotton batting). Use enough to make a hard-pressed ball about the size of an egg. Wrap the stuffing with the cloth and pull all the sides into your hand to stretch the cloth over the stuffing. When you need a point, take one end of the pad and squeeze it out to form a point, then press it onto the work with your first finger. (Another suggestion: one of our local customers, is an old hand at French polishing; he uses foam rubber inside the cloth - a slight squeeze pushes out the polish; less pressure soaks it quickly back into the pad for immediate control.)

The Polish: Generally, about 10 oz., of our French polish thinner (FFPT), which is a high grade ethyl alcohol, will dilute 1 oz. by weight (2 oz. by volume) of our shellac. The remaining thinner can be used for spiriting off, thinning the pad mixture, pouring into the pad, keeping some in a bottle to keep the pad wet, etc.

Measure out small portions of the shellac and thinner as you need them and keep both the thinner and the F.P. tightly capped - they are deliquescent and draw water from the air. The mixed F.P. has a shelf life of about 9 months at the most. The dilution can vary considerably, but the ratio of 10 fluid ounces to 1 ounce by weight of shellac is recommended. For measuring out the proper dilutions, use a simple kitchen measuring cup, a chemists burette or pipette, level shovelsfull or whatever; the more accurate, the better control you will have. For mixing, any clean jar with a tight fitting lid will do, although smaller is better. For storing mixed shellac, minimal air space above the solution is best. Be sure the lid you use is unwaxed, as the thinner will dissolve the wax. Turn the jar over once or twice during the day. It should dissolve easily overnight. For polishing, keep it in a small, 4 oz. squirt bottle.

BEGINNING ON FILLED OR NON-POROUS WOOD:

Load the pad with polish from the squirt bottle until it leaves a good, wet streak on dry wood. Then, tap it hard into your palm to disperse the F.P. and to flatten the pad. Keeping the pad very tightly held and the wrist stiff, lay on long, straight strokes, one after another, covering the whole surface until the surface is wet. In a few minutes the process can be repeated, and so on until the finish begins to "build" (shine). The pad is now dry at this point. Use small, circular motions which drag a little but not too much. About 2"-4" diameter circles, working gradually around and over the whole surface seem to work the best. The pad must never stop on the surface - it is lifted off and put on while still in motion. This is an absolute rule and must become a habit. The circular strokes are the fastest builders, but vary them with long, narrow "figure-8" strokes which reach right across the edge of the instrument.

Sticking vs. Building: If you keep the pad too wet with polish, it will pull up and melt what you have laid down previously. If you keep it too dry, you will rub without building. The pad should leave a smear that dries almost when it is laid down. The movements should be quick and light when the pad is a little wet, slower and heavier when it is drier. In order to avoid sticking, a small amount of fine mineral oil, poppyseed oil, linseed oil or other light oil can be used as a lubricant. This must be kept to a minimum as it tends to soften the final polish and can be nearly impossible to remove. You can use fine mineral oil, spreading a drop over a fairly wide area of the work.

"Recharge" the pad by squirting polish directly onto the surface then, tapping it into the palm of the hand. The cloth over the pad must be kept tight and a tight grip must be kept on the whole pad.

Difficuit Areas: Guitars are usually polished before the bridge is put on. The bridge area is marked (just a hair inside the actual bridge size) after the polish has dried and then scraped clean of polish with a chisel. Then the bridge is glued on.

The really difficult area is where the top meets the side of the fingerboard. The only solution to this problem is to make sure that every time you pass that area, you polish it with the point of the rubber in circular and straight back and forth motions. Otherwise, it will build more slowly than other areas and appear streaked and pale.

Rough Surface: Sometimes you will use too wet a pad and while not really pulling up the finish, it will leave the finish in a way that is hard to remove. Give the polish at least a few hours to dry, and then with #600 wet/dry paper, a rubber block and some coal oil (kerosene) for lubricant, you very carefully sand the surface smooth. You can then begin to polish again on a smooth surface.

Spraying French Polish: You may spray F.P. It's a great time saver. Since no oil is used, quite a hard smooth body can be produced very quickly. It's also nice for areas like the machine head slots, which are hard to reach.

Staining: With the two packets of shellac we supply, you may achieve a range of color by mixing the amber with the blond and still retain good transparency. If it is put on at an even thickness, the color will be even. If you desire to darken the color, about halfway through the bodying process, you can add liquid stain directly to the polish in small amounts. Keep the colored surface even and do not apply color to a rough surface that is to be smoothed out later.

Drying: Usually at one or two points during polishing, the surface becomes rather thick and tacky. These are dangerous points but they also allow you to move the polish around to fill holes, etc. to the greatest extent. It is best to put the instrument aside for 2 or 3 (or more) hours to let the finish set before going on.

Spiriting Off: This is the most difficult part of French polishing and may require some practice. As you finish the last stages of the bodying process, begin to add thinner instead of F.P. to your pad and work without oil. Keep the pad dry and rub fairly fast and press hard. This will usually, in time, bring up a shine and remove the oil that has been used in bodying. The high pressure tends to compress the finish and force out the oil while glazing the surface.

Another Method: For those who do not F.P. enough to keep in practice, the final surfacing or glazing can be done very nicely with our FSP polish. Let the finish dry completely (a couple of days, if possible) then, with terrycloth or some soft cotton, rub the surface very hard with FSP until a perfect shine comes up. You might prefer this rather softer shine to the brilliance of a spirited off glaze.

Some Points to Remember: F.P. is an art and an acquired skill. It takes some time to learn, so don't give up with your first try. The more you practice, the better you'll become.

The best materials are a must. Shellac comes in all qualities from garbage to gold. The best is easier to build and to spirit off. It lasts and wears much longer, and produces a more beautIful and transparent finish.

TECHNICAL TERMS

Cold-Checking: Fine cracks that often run like spiderwebs through the finish. They are caused by sudden changes In temperature in a finish not elastic enough, or, which does not expand and contract at a similar rate to wood. Or, the finish simply may not be tough enough. Old lacquer finishes nearly always show evidence of cold-checking. The elasticizers have dried up and the finish becomes too brittle to resist temperature changes.

Wash Coat: A thinned or fairly fluid coat of finish put on the raw wood, usually to seal it, reduce its absorbency and to provide a wood-penetrating base for the later coats.

Pad: A pad ("fad" or "rubber") is a cloth surrounding some absorbent material and used, one might say, as a dryish swab to apply finish.

Text From The Luthiers' Mercantile Catalog - 1993

Previous | Next | Top | Construction Tutorials | Home

- 9.7 -