Steve's Place

Review of show at the Shrine Auditorium Los Angeles,CA
date of show unknown

Review from Melody Maker April 5,1975




Los Angeles: Robin Trower's ascent to stardom can be directly related to the void left by the demise of powertrios. His sheer volume and primal attack can be linked to Hendrix and Cream.
At Los Angeles Shrine Auditorium, a sold out throng proved receptive to all of Robin's variations on a theme. His songs have an alarming sameness about them, testifying to the authors penchant for heavy metal licks.
 And while Jim Dewar's vocals were totally obscured by the horrendous sound system, and Bill Lordan's perfunctory drumming and obligatory (but thankfully) shortsolo plodded along, Robin played on, stunning the crowd with his feedback manipulation.
 Selections from his albums comprised the repertoire, although i, it was nearly impossible to disern one song from the next, so similar is the phrasing and melody of each. By far the best was from the first LP. Here, Robin showed a more subtle approach, allowing the content of the song to sustain the energy rather than let his wall of Marshalls do the work for him.
 These obvious shortcomings were not so obvious to the crowd. Thunderous ovations greeted each tune and there were three encores.



Review from someone who was there ... (thanks Mike)
I don't know what show Melody Maker saw but it wasn't the 3/16/75 show at the Shrine auditorium in Los Angeles. I can't let either the grand lady ( The Shrine), Robin or the review rest without a rebuke. I was sitting 19th row center (see scan). Granted, a Shrine audio sweet spot. But then again, The Shrine sounded good to great no matter where you were ( and still does!) . With the exception of the sub main floor walkway running the length on the stage  and directly in from of it and the 1st row. The heads of the press gallery, if they were standing tall,  would be at your foot, if you were sitting in the front row. Yeah the sound probably blew down there. To the rest of us regular folk the sound was spectacular. My H.S. girlfriend (we saw concerts every week sometimes 2-3
times a week in L.A. 1974-1977) wasn't into seeing Robin at all, and was blown away. The guy in front of us, a friendly Trowerhead, will always be remembered. He wore thick nerdy blackframed glasses held together by tape at the nose and both arms. Which had me snickering,until the show started. I don't recall ever seeing anyone anywhere more into a show than this guy was. Fact of the matter is, most of the crowd went apeshit. As much as I liked Bridge Of Sighs and the touring lp, I was out of my league (at that time) here. One of these rare shows ( and these are the ones you live for folks) that actually , at least for me, leave you almost afraid to ever see the performer again, or pick up thier latest release after the fact. Cause no matter how good the next show or record
is it's gonna pale after what you just saw/heard. I've read the Robin was recording alot shows around this time. I sure would love to hear Shrine 3/16/75 again. I don't recall the set being much different than the Travis Street  Dallas 3/20/75 tape ( which I really enjoy) , but the performance, at least to my memory was well , see above. I knew there was a reason I never paid much attention to Melody Maker.  Mike


This is a great example of how a bad reviewer can really distort how the show went. Right up to the end he seems to be saying the show was bad "sameness of the songs" ...obscured vocals"..."plodding drums" etc..... and then the very last thing is sort of like
" oh ya, they got thunderous appluase and three encores"
THREE encores!!! ...Sounds like a great show and that the crowd loved it!  This guy probably heard two Trower tunes in his life and then started reviewing shows.
                                                                                                                            - Steve

             Back to the history list