Overview & Objectives

Welcome to my virtual seminar on  Graphic Novel Online Reviews. 

The goals of this presentation are to:

  • Introduce you to online reviews of graphic novels
  • Encourage you to explore & discuss sources of online reviews and their usefulness for various purposes
  • Leave you with a good list of online resources to aid your graphic novel collection development
  • Leave you with a list of online resources to aid you in defending graphic novels in the event your selections are challenged
I would like to introduce you to a very special virtual guest. Da Da Da, Da! Da Da...

The illustrious Robin Brenner of No Flying No Tights will be dropping in to our discussion. 

(While working on my website evaluation I contacted Robin to clarify some questions I had. She responded to me very promptly and then offered to virtually visit the class. Who could say no to an offer like that?)

Please check out the following links so that we may all have a common foundation for the Virtual Seminar discussion.
Art Bomb
- Browse books by genre for reviews
Beeks Books
- Skim the list (If it has a particular order, it escapes me.)
Bob's Comic Reviews
- Reviews alphabetized by author under headings
Book Wholesalers, Inc. (BWI) TITLETALES
- It's free to register (You must register to search the site.)
- Advanced search allows many options
- Useful information in the display includes recommended grade levels, reviews and cataloguing information
Comic Books for Young Adults by Michael R. Lavin
- Recommended (but not reviewed) titles listed first by age and interest, then by genre

The Comics Get Serious: Graphic Novels and Other Stuff by D. Aviva Rothschild, author of Graphic Novels: A Bibliographic Guide to Book-Length Comics
- Reviews of 144 graphic novels at last count, organized by Title, Subject/Genre

The Comics Journal
Comic Readers
- Browse the archives or search
Comic World News
Comics Worth Reading 
- Recommendations, Manga Reviews, Independent Comics Reviews, DC Comics Reviews, Marvel Comics Reviews
Darkhorse
- Browse by Titles, Creators or Subjects for a short synopsis (not review) with age level
Diamond Bookshelf
- Reviews written by Kat Kan who also writes a column Graphically Speaking in Voice of Youth Advocates (VOYA)
Fanboy Planet
- Comics Preview Spotlight 
Follet's TITLEWAVE
- It's free to register (You must register to search the site.)
- Click on collection development to set the parameters of your search
- The results list includes reading and interest level, excerpts from review journals (i.e.: Booklist)
Fourth Rail
- Skim the archives for titles
Graphic Novel Review
- First Issue Sept. 2004
Grovel.org.uk The source for Graphic Novels
- Browse by titles, writers or artists
Guardians of the North
- A good site for bringing attention to Canadian Comics
Graphic Novels Tired of Superman? How About Trying Something New? by April Spisak & Ria Newhouse
- Short annotations of graphic novels in listed by fiction and non-fiction 

Graphic Novel Roundup by Steve Weiner, author of 101 Best Graphic Novels
-
A regular column in School Library Journal, Steve Wiener writes short reviews that include age level appropriateness
(If you have trouble accessing the articles you may sign up for a 30 day free trial.)

icomics
- Best of lists or search by title 
Lambiek Comiclopedia
- This site is made up of author author biographies with mentions of their work
The Librarian's Guide to Anime and Manga by Gilles Poitras, author of Anime Essentials
- There are recommended lists of Anime (listed alphabetically by title) and Manga (listed by both author and title)
Manga Maniacs
- Reviews listed alphabetically by series
- Series are colour coded for appropriateness 
Need Coffee
- Reviews listed alphabetically by title
MARSimport
- Search by title or browse by title, series, genre, publisher, creator, price or language for info and descriptions (no reviews)
Ninth Art
- Search full length reviews with cover art and inside pages
No Flying No Tights by Robin Brenner and cohorts
- Reviews by genre or search by creator/author, title or publisher
Rambles
- Reviews are listed alphabetically by title within publisher groupings
reads4teens
- short reviews by teens
SBC Silver Bullet Comic Books
- Line of Fire reviews of comics
Sequential Tart: The Report Card
- Reviews in each issue may be sorted in several ways
Spiderfan
- Search
Suspended Animation
- \skim the tiles in each year's list
Toonopedia: A Vast Repository of Toonological Knowledge
- From The Yellow Kid to the present
top-book-reviews
- Search Graphic Novels and browse by genre

What Teens Want - Thirty Graphic Novels You Can't Live Without recommended by Michele Gorman, author of: Getting Graphic! Using Graphic Novels to Promote Literacy with Preteens and Teens

Michele’s list has been reprinted with title covers in Teens Know on the Harris County Public Library Site

Winnipeg Public Library Staff Picks
- Short annotations of a handful of graphic novels

I have also included suggested reading which may help you to gain a broader understanding of the topic.  Please read what seems useful to you.  I'm sure we are all indifferent places in graphic novel collection development. 

Home | Overview & Objectives | Suggested Reading | Issues to Consider | Summary | References

Posted by Janice Biebrich

Ms. Biebrich's Website

Posted Posted October 19/04