Isobarik
loading has become pretty popular for
car audio use in the last few years.
Again this is not a new concept, having
been originally introduced by Harry
Olson in the early 1950's. Technically,
"isobarik" is not really an
enclosure type; it is a loading method.
This loading method involves the
coupling of two woofers to work
together as one unit. This is typically
accomplished either by placing two
woofers face to face or by coupling two
woofers with a small chamber. The
result of coupling the two speakers is
that the coupled pair (iso-group) can
now produce the same frequency response
in half the box volume as a single
speaker of the same type would require.
For example, if a speaker is optimized
for performance in a 1 cu.ft. sealed
enclosure, one iso-group of the same
speakers can achieve the same low
frequency extension and overall
response characteristics in a 0.5 cu.ft.
sealed enclosure.
There is, of course, a penalty
involved. Whenever you use isobarik
loading, you are sacrificing 3dB of
efficiency compared to a single driver
in twice the air space. In practical
terms, this is not usually a big deal
since the powerhandling is doubled (two
speakers instead of one) and the
impedance is typically cut in half if
we parallel the two speakers (twice the
power, assuming the amplifier can
deliver the necessary current.) The end
result is about the same output as the
single driver in the bigger box but at
twice the amplifier power (and twice
the speaker cost.)
Isobarik loading can be used
within any enclosure type, including
bandpass designs. The ported and
bandpass isobarik designs can be
difficult to design and build due to
very small enclosures with large port
requirements. Isobarik bandpass
designs, in particular, can be
literally impossible to build with
certain speakers. There are some things
to look out for with each type of
isobarik design, such as mechanical
noise and uneven heat dissipation which
can present potential sound quality and
reliability problems. All the methods
which involve opposite cone motion
require that the speakers be wired in
reverse polarity relative to each
other. These designs also provide a
performance advantage in that their
opposed cone motion averages out
suspension non-linearities (differences
in inward and outward suspension
control,) which reduces distortion.
If you are strapped for space
and can afford the extra speakers and
more complex enclosure, the ability to
have a compact subwoofer system with no
real sacrifice in performance is well
worth the extra effort and expense. On
the other hand, if you have a lot of
space and are looking to get the
maximum amount of output without
sacrificing sound quality, using
multiple iso-groups can give you the
best cone area/box volume ratio while
still retaining good fidelity.
|