• Theme 3– Irresponsibility of Science


Warrick describes that "Frankenstein's rejection of his own creation" is an example of the irresponsibility of science... Take another look at the Frankenstein timeline and think about Dr. Frankensteins actions...

Frankenstein timeline

Think about the following:

  • Do you agree or disagree with Warrick that Dr.Frankenstein was irresponsible for turning his back on the monster?
  • Could Dr. Frankenstein have done something differently in order to change or avoid the outcome of the story?
  • What kinds of responsibilities come with inventions and scientific experiments?

 

Case Study: Thalidomide

Thalidomide can be looked at as an invention or new technology that was meant to be helpful and improve the lives of people but ended up in disaster...

"Thalidomide first appeared in Germany on 1st October 1957. It was marketed as a sedative with apparently remarkably few side effects. The Drug Company who developed it believed it was so safe it was suitable for prescribing to pregnant women to help combat morning sickness.

It was quickly being prescribed to thousands of women and spread to most corners of the globe. Nobody had any idea of what was to follow. Drug testing procedures were far more relaxed at this time, and although tests had taken place on thalidomide, they didn't reveal any of its tetragenic (roughly meaning causing malformations) properties. In most countries, drug companies were not required to submit testing results to the appropriate government agencies.

The tests on thalidomide were conducted on rodents which metabolise the drug in a different way to humans. Later tests on rabbits and monkeys produced the same horrific side effects as in humans.

Some thalidomide babies Towards the end of the fifties, children began to be born with shocking disabilities. It was not immediately obvious what the cause of this was. Probably the most renowned is Pharcomelia, the name given to the flipper-like limbs which appeared on the children of women who took thalidomide. Babies effected by this tragedy were given the name 'Thalidomide Babies'."


Taken from: http://www.chm.bris.ac.uk/motm/thalidomide/first.html

 

After reading the case study on Thalidomide answer the following questions:
  • What kinds of responsibilities come with inventions and scientific experiments?
  • Who is responsible for the disaster in the case of Frankenstien?
  • Who is responsible for the disaster in the case of the Thalidomide Babies?

Create a list of the top 5 'Ethical Practices' or 'Laws' that you think Scientists should follow when approaching the creation of a new invention. Support your 'laws' with reasons as to why each one would be an important law to follow...

The Top 5 Ethical Laws that Scientists and Inventors must follow:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.