What people thought of Jimmy?


Carroll Baker, co-star in Giant:

"Jimmy was Jimmy - maybe impossible to know really well.  But wasn't that part of his fascination after all?"
 

Bill Bast, friend of Dean's:

"It was his philosophy that an actor had to do everything, had to experiment with everything, which certainly gave him license to do anything he wanted to do."
 

Andy Brown, local resident of Mendocino:

"Jimmy played catch once with me and my friends the Silvas in Dr. Preston's yard between 'shoots,' when he wasn't doing anything.  He was good at throwing a baseball around and was pretty patient with us kids."
 

Richard Davalos, co-star in East of Eden:

"Jimmy didn't know how to take hard criticism.  He had no acting persona that could soak it up and deal with it and not let it get through to him too personally.  It just bewildered him.  Then he'd have to sort himself out, before he could sort out what was wrong in the acting.  His acting style was dangerous, unpredictable.  Just being in a scene with him could be an unnerving experience.  He had that instinct to disturb.  We were so into those roles, me and Jimmy.  We became so much like the characters we were playing, it was frightening; working on that movie affected all of us in it because of the depths we reached in the characterization.  In my case, it took me years to get over it."
 

Sammy Davis Jr., friend of Dean's:

"He did his number, and did it better than anyone in the world."
 

Ann Doran, co-star in Rebel Without a Cause:

"He liked to rehearse...at any time-one, two, or three o'clock in the morning.  Rather than disturb my family, he would come to my house during the night, and we might discuss characterizations.  He would drink gallons of coffee and even smoked marijuana until I told him it was making me sick.  Sometimes he complained about people who tried to intrude in his life or hoped to get someplace on his coattails.  Though I'm a great talker, I did a lot of listening.  He widened my life."
 

Julie Harris, co-star in East of Eden:

"...You see, he was mercurial, unpredictable, always putting you on, which I didn't mind because he was very beguiling - there was something very sweet about him even though he was sort of a bad boy.  He was like a Tom Sawyer to me ... he did manipulate people and he knew he was doing it."

"It's awful when somebody is taken away from you that young and when you're just thinking of all the wonderful things they're gonna do."

"I really loved him and I really loved working with him.  It was a unique experience in my life, I never worked with an actor again that was quite that way."
 

Dennis Hopper, actor and director:

"I was just devastated by his death.  I don't think I've ever gotten over it.  It blew my whole sense of destiny and how things operate in this strange life that we're all involved in here on this planet.  But I just couldn't believe that somebody as talented as gifted and extraordinary as James Dean die before his potential was fulfilled..."
 

Hedda Hopper, Hollywood Writer:

"I couldn't remember ever having seen a young man with such power, so many facets of expression, so much sheer invention as this actor."
 

Rock Hudson, co-star in Giant:

"Dean was hard to be around...never smiled...had no manners.  And he was rough to do a scene with...in the giving and the taking...he was just a taker."

"Before coming on the set he used to warm up like a fighter before a contest.  He never stepped into camera range without first jumping into the air with his knees up under his chin, or running at full speed around the set shrieking like a bird of prey."

"I didn't particularly like him, personally.  But that didn't matter.  Jimmy was certainly effective in the role, especially in the younger part.  Mind you, he only made three films.  He was a little guy and he thought little...He was brilliant as the young man, but he didn't know what to do with the old man.  As a matter of fact, he had a long monologue in an empty banquet room that was cut down to the nub because he couldn't sustain it...Also, Jimmy was dead before the picture was over, and his dialogue had to be looped because Jimmy had played it too drunk and you couldn't hear it.  So they got another actor to do it.  Nick Adams."
 

Elia Kazan, Director of East of Eden:

"He was a heap of twisted legs and denim rags, looking resentful for no particular reason.  I didn't like the expression on his face, so I kept him waiting.  I also wanted to see how he'd react to that.  It seemed that I'd outtoughed him, because when I called him in he'd dropped the belligerent pose.  We tried to talk, but conversation was not his gift, so we sat looking at each other.  He asked me if I wanted to ride on the back of his motorbike; I didn't enjoy the ride.  He was showing off - a country boy not impressed with big-city traffic.  When I got back to the office I called Paul and told him this kid actually was Cal Trask."

"I doubt that Jimmy would ever have got through East of Eden except for an angel on our set.  Her name was Julie Harris, and she was goodness itself with Dean, kind and patient and everlastingly sympathetic."

"He was never more than a limited actor, and he was a highly neurotic young man-obviously sick, and he got more so.  His face was very poetic-wonderful, and very painful, full of desolation.  There are moments when you say, "Oh, God, he's so handsome-what's being lost here?  What goodness is being lost here?"  Directing him was like directing the faithful Lassie.  I either lectured him or terrorized him, flattered him furiously, tapped him on the shoulder, or kicked his backside.  He was so instinctive and so stupid in many ways-and most of all I had the impression of someone who was a cripple inside.  He was not like Brando.  People compared them, but there was no similarity.  He was a far, far sicker kid, and Brando's not sick, he's just troubled."

"Dean was impossible, he was always cutting in on his lines, saying the wrong lines...[Raymond] Massey had learned the script exactly...he would say to me 'He's not saying the lines.' I say, 'All right, I'll get him to say the lines.'..I was tricky, I let Jimmy do it the way he wanted because it irritated him [Raymond Massey]."

"Do you think I would do anything to stop that antagonism?  No, I increased it, I let it go...because it was the central thing that I photographed.  I didn't photograph them enjoying those damn lines, although the lines were good.  But what I photographed was their relationship to each other.  The absolute hatred that Ray Massey felt for Jimmy Dean, and the hatred Jimmy Dean felt for Ray Massey.  That's precious man, you can't get that, no director can get that!"
 

Martin Landau, actor and friend of Dean's:

"He was the fellow who all teenagers of this country and all of the young people in their twenties said, Yes, that's how I felt.  Yes, that's me, I understand that person...We always watched grown-ups in movies.  We had never really seen a true portrayal or a representation of the turmoil that was being felt by most young people."
 

Toni Lemos, local resident of Mendocino:

"He was young, full of vim and vigor and dressed like a showoff.  He wasn't that great at the time.  He was just starting out and was trying to hold his own with actors like Raymond Massey.  But Jimmy worked at it, only to become famous after he died."
 

Leonard Maltin, movie critic:

"I can't think of another actor who acquired stardom so quickly, who held it for such a short time, and then kept it for such a long time.  James Dean became a star in one calendar year, and then he left us.  But he's still being talked about, he's still being revered, he's still being iconized forty years later.  I don't think there's another example like it in the entire history of movies."
 

Raymond Massey, co-star who endured Dean during East of Eden:

"Simple technicalities such as moving on cue and finding his marks were beneath his consideration."

"You never know what he's going to do.  Make him read the lines the way they're written!"

"So Gadge (Kazan) endured the slouchings, the eye-poppings, the mutterings and all the willful eccentricities...he said to me one morning...'Bear with me Ray, I'm getting solid gold!'"
 

Sal Mineo, co-star in Rebel Without a Cause, tells about the last time he saw Jimmy:

"Just outside the commissary, a little old man with a mustache passed by.  I didn't know him, but, as he passed, I caught him smiling.  That grim gave him away.  It was Jimmy - with a mustache, hair pushed back, shoulders hunched, still in the part of an old man."
 

Nicholas Ray, Director of Rebel Without a Cause:

"I've never met anyone with the ability of Dean.  He cannot be compared with any actor, present or past.  I'm sure he'll bring performances to the screen the likes of which haven't yet been thought of."

"To work with him...meant exploring his nature, trying to understand it; without this, his powers of expression were frozen."
 

Leonard Rosenman, friend of Jimmy's and music composer for East of Eden and Rebel Without a Cause:

"I really think Jimmy had no idea in the world who or what he was.  Obviously he identified with the three movie roles he had, but I think they were given to him because he was those roles, or in some ways they were created for him - and it all had to do with confusion!"
 

Roy Schatt, photographer and friend of Dean's:

"He could be sullen and childish...but he could also use his feelings of outrage to create outlandish situations that often bordered on the dangerous."
 

Martin Sheen, actor:

"When I was a young actor in New York there was a saying that if Marlon Brando changed the way actors acted, James Dean changed the way people lived.  I believe that."
 

Lois Smith, co-star in East of Eden:

"At that time, he was a kid.  It was his first Hollywood experience.  Of course, there was no 'James Dean cult' in those days.  He was just another actor.  I don't know, I just have no response to the cult thing.  I don't understand cult figures.  I guess the characters he played symbolized the postwar generation gap.  Anyway, he was awfully good in the film."
 

George Stevens, Director of Giant:

"He worked hard to get publicity and always had a photographer with him.  He had a fine concept of how Jimmy Dean could be made popular, and he and his personally attached cameraman roamed around looking for the right people to be photographed with.  He did this with Elizabeth Taylor, Edna Ferber and many others."
 

Elizabeth Taylor, co-star in Giant:

"Sometimes Jimmy and I would sit up until three in the morning talking and he would tell me about his past life, his conflicts and some of his loves and tragedies.  And the next day it was almost as if he didn't want to recognize me, or to remember that he had revealed so much of himself the night before.  And so he would pass me and ignore me, or just give me a cursory nod of the head.  And then it took a day or two to become my friend again.  I found all that hard to understand."
 

Casper Van Dien, actor:

"He defined my generation, he defined your generation, he defined it all.  I mean if you look at him, there's no way you can say that he didn't impact your life in some way... you know he impacted your life, he meant something to you..."
 

Andy Warhol, artist:

"James Dean made just three pictures, but even if he had made only one he would still be the greatest male star of the '50s.  The pictures are East of Eden, Rebel Without a Cause, Giant.  Just the titles evoke epic visions, and all three films live up to their titles, constituting a three part heroic poem on atomic age youth, its beauties and its obsessions...James Dean was the perfect embodiment of an eternal struggle.  It might be innocence struggling with experience, youth with age, or man with his image.  But in every aspect his struggle was a mirror to a generation of rebels without a cause.  His anguish was exquisitely genuine on and off the screen; his moments of joy were rare and precious.  He is not our hero because he was perfect, but because he perfectly represented the damaged but beautiful soul of our time..."
 

Jane Withers, co-star in Giant:

"Jimmy was very, very stern, and very concentrating on what he was doing - which was understandable.  And I think they could've been real special friends (Rock Hudson and James Dean), if they had the time to be."

"In the beginning, I was naturally very interested in Jimmy as an actor and as a person.  I'd never ever met him and he stayed very much to himself - and was very, very distant.  So, I thought, okay, I will respect that and his privacy.  So, I stayed very distant, but he was the only one I did [stay away from] because everybody else were like teddy bears.  You know and I love teddy bears.  So, it took a while for us to finally kind of share thoughts.  But he didn't allow that, if I would just say even 'Good Morning,' he'd say, 'Hi,' and sort of the roll of the eyes and so on.  But no real, nothing in the way of communication.  So finally I was taking pictures as I usually do of everybody and having a wonderful time.  And so he finally came up to me one day and he said, 'You don't take any pictures of me.'  And I said, 'Well, I wouldn't think of it.  You obviously enjoy being by yourself because you never come around and mingle with us, especially me.  I tried very hard to respect people's wishes as best I can.  I wouldn't dream of bothering you in any way, shape, or form.'  He said, 'Well, that's all right.  If you want to take some pictures of me, I don't mind.'  I said, 'That would be super.  I'd love that.'  So, that was the beginning, that was the first step, and the steps came more regularly - and more often."                           
   

Natalie Wood, co-star in Rebel Without a Cause:

"He was incredibly encouraging and sweet."

"He was fascinated by the stories that were written on him.  He did all he could to find out how other people saw him and what they thought about him."
 

Back to Main Page