Printable Microsoft Word (.doc file) of this & other documents can be found on my download page http://members.shaw.ca/deercroft/download.html
FEATURE |
AC Aeroplan Super Elite (SE) |
CO One Pass Platinum Elite |
NH Elite Diamond (DI) |
OZ Diamond (DI) / |
LH Miles and More Senator /HON Circle (HON) |
NZ AirPoints Gold Elite (GE) |
SK EuroBonus Gold (EBG) |
TK Miles and Smiles Elite Plus |
UA Mileage Plus 1K (1K) |
US Dividend Miles Chairmen's Preferred (CP) |
Paid 1st COS Bonus |
50% |
25% base/50% Q CO metal |
50% (int'l) |
50% |
200% |
varies, approx 250% |
100% |
50% |
50% |
50% |
Paid Bus. COS Bonus |
25% in J (50% AC Canada-US/Caribbean in J/C; 25% manual credit AC int'l RTW C) |
25% base/50% Q CO metal |
25% (int'l); 50% dom. "SuperSeat" |
25% |
100% |
varies by route, approx 125% |
100% (50% on full Y SK flights) |
50% on TK and 25-50% |
25%; 50% Q on UA/US & LH US-Europe |
25-50%; 50% Q US/HP, UA & NH |
COS Bonus = status mi. |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y (UA/US & LH US-Europe) |
Y (US/HP, UA & NH) |
*Access to Star Gold Lounges if flying |
Y (&AC Maple Leaf lounges only on AC/ |
Y; USA Clubs on same day dom./ intern'l connection when flying int'l ticket |
Y |
Y (DI/DP-OZ business/ PL-OZ 1st class lounge) |
Y (also to LH Senator, arriving or departing, & SK RVC Gold) |
Y (with up to 5 guests in NZ lounges, except not in regional Koru Club) |
Y (& BM Euroclass, UK& all LH Senator); all SK Scandinavian, arriving or departing |
Y |
Y; US RCC/Club ONLY same day dom./ intern'l connection when flying int'l ticket |
Y; US RCC & Club ONLY same day dom./ int'l connection on int'l ticket |
|
100K or 95 segments |
75K (or 90 points-about 45 segments in higher fare classes, 90 segments in lower fare classes) |
100K Premium pts (50K must be on NH) / no qualifying by segments starting 2008; Premium pts = base miles X COS X route multiplier |
DI/DP-40K/100K or 50/100 OZ segments (every 24 months from reference day); PL-1000K/1000 OZ segments (life) |
100K (non-Germany) OR 130K Germany; |
1500 Q points; 900 on NZ metal; 1350 for Australia / Norfolk Is., 800 on NZ metal; 10% less to requalify |
miles |
80K in 12 months; 40K/60K in 1/2 years to renew |
100K (or 100 segments) |
100K (or 120 segments) |
% Bonus for Elite |
§0-100 on AC metal; 0-25 LH, NH, BD; on base miles only |
100% on CO metal; 500 mile minimum |
125 on NH metal |
10/15/20% for DI/DP/PL on OZ metal |
25 full Miles & More members, AC, UA and US base miles based on distance flown or, in Europe, fixed miles (counts as status) |
0 |
25 on SK, airBaltic, Blue1, Estonian, & Wideroe (except dom. Norway); counts as status |
100% Q miles on TK business; purchase up to 10K Q miles for 240 Euro |
100 (UA &. UA code share on LH, US & LH US-Europe) |
100 on US/HP, UA, NH |
+Special Bonus Miles |
gift or 25K^ at 150K Q; 40K^ @200K Q, 75K^ @250K Q, 150K^ @300K Q (see below!) |
50% Q miles on all Y and B econo fares on CO flights any fare; 250 Q mile min |
100% Q NH Japan domestic, 50% NH to China (after COS multiplier applied) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
+Upgrades- Domestic |
see next--international upgrades are also good for North American flights |
instant upgrades Y and B fares at time of ticketing; space available at 5 days for all other fares for member and companion; mileage based upgrades 5 15K miles |
40 upgrade points for qualify/requalify plus 2 for every 10K Q miles over 100K Q minimum qualify |
Y purchase for 3K miles |
Y (except L,T); purchase for 10K-15K miles; confirmable at time of reservation; 2 1-way European upgrades on requalifying; HON get 6 on requalifying and 2 for birthday (unofficial) |
N |
purchase for 10K+ points, valid from flex fares in Europe; for member / companion |
2 certificates/ yr good for domestic or int'l, non-transferable; also purchase upgrades for miles |
500 mi NA -- 4 every 10K Q, confirm. 100 hr.; 2 1-way 1-class transferable HK49 / 10K Q miles—max of 8; confirm. @ res. |
Unlimited N. Am./ Latin Am./ Carib., request 7 days prior OR anytime full coach on US (Y,B,U)/HP (Y,H) |
+Upgrades 1-class Int'l |
§6 SWU or 4 SWU/ 4 NA or 2 SSWU/ 2 SWU or 2 SSWU/ 4 NA on qualifying & 2 SWU @ 20, 60, 90, 105, 135, 150K & every 30K after; 2 SSWU @40, 75, 120, 165K & every 30K Q after; confirm at ticketing Y/M/U; 7 days other fares |
- instant upgrades Y and B fares at time of ticketing and space available at 5 days all other fares for member and companion, all but longest haul flights |
- see above for earning; 4 points to upgrade domestic, 8 for int’l business and 15 for int’l first except China/Asia resorts=5 points business and 7 first |
purchase for miles (varies) |
Y (except S,W); purchase for 35K-75K miles; confirmable at time of reservation; 2 European upgrades = 1 international |
2 segments/yr, transferable, confirm. 12 months, also good on reward travel, standby or higher cost at reservation one-way upgrades for points |
purchase for up to 30000 points (from any fare outside Europe; use on a standby basis), for member / companion |
2 certificates/ yr good for domestic or int'l, non-transferable; also purchase upgrades for miles |
6 SWU; +2 @ 150K EQM /150 EQS & every 50K EQM/50 EQS after; buy upgrades from select (non-deep discount) fares for 10-60K miles—confirm @ res. |
2 HI/Europe (& 2 companion) good on Y,B,M, H,Q fares |
Reward notes# |
no blackout on AC; if not oversold, seat even if award seat unavailable for +30% points |
better Econo and BusinessFirst reward availability |
extensive reward list; any revenue seat for 2x miles even if normal reward unavailable |
no blackout OZ; 10% off multiple same itinerary redemptions |
50% companion awards |
|
50% off awards for under 17 year old children |
no blackout on TK for member; if not oversold, seat even if award seat unavailable |
no blackouts on standard awards |
no blackouts on standard awards |
Other Bonuses (all have priority check-in, waitlist, standby, baggage) (Star Gold members get at least 1 extra piece if piece concept applies or 20 kg if weight concept applies on any |
§Choice of 2 of :
AND Choice of 2 of:
AND Choice of 1 of:
---------------------------
|
|
|
plus for PL:
|
HON: SEN benefits plus
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other Minuses |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
!, +, *, ** -- see last page
COMPARISON OF Middle Tier Star Alliance (
) Gold Frequent Flyer Programs
Air Canada (AC), Air China (CA), ANA (NH), British Midland (BD), CO (Continental), Air New Zealand (NZ), Singapore (SQ), South African (SA), Spanair (JK), TAP Air Portugal (TP), Thai (TG), United (UA), and US Air (US) PAGE 2 of 2 NOTE: Middle Tier on some carriers not shown if not Star Gold (LH, SAS); some Top Tiers (e.g. SQ BD CA) only equivalent in benefits to most Middle Tier programs so are placed in Middle Tier.
FEATURE |
AC Aeroplan Elite (E) |
Air China Companion Gold (G)/ Platinum (PL) |
CO One Pass Gold Elite |
NH Elite |
BD Diamond Club |
NZ AirPoints Gold (G) |
SQ Solitaire PPS Club/PPS Club/ KrisFlyer Elite Gold (eff Sep 2007) |
SA Voyageur Gold/ Platinum* |
JK Spanair Plus Gold |
TP Victoria Gold Winner |
TG Royal Orchid Plus Gold |
TK Miles and Smiles Elite |
UA Mileage Plus Premier Exec (PE) |
US Dividend Miles Platinum/ Gold Preferred (PP/GP) |
Paid 1st COS Bonus |
50% |
50% |
25% base/50% Q CO metal |
50% (int'l) |
200% (100% SQ) |
varies by route, approx 250% |
50% |
50% |
varies by route, approx 312% |
100% TAP |
50% |
50% |
50% |
50% |
Paid Bus. COS Bonus |
25% in J (50% AC Canada-US/Caribbean in J/C; 25% manual credit AC int'l RTW C Class) |
30% |
25% base/50% Q CO metal |
25% (int'l); 50% dom. "SuperSeat" |
100% (50% SQ) |
varies by route, approx 125% |
25% |
25% |
varies by route, approx 200-300% |
50% TAP |
25% |
50% on TK and 25-50% |
25%; 50% Q on UA/US & LH US-Europe |
25-50%; 50% Q US/HP, UA & NH |
COS Bonus = status mi. |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y |
Y |
Y (all |
Y (all |
Y? |
Y (all |
Y |
Y (all |
Y (UA/US & LH US-Europe) |
Y (US/HP, UA & NH) |
*Access to Star Gold Lounges if flying |
Y (& to AC Arrivals) |
Y |
Y; USA Clubs on same day dom./ intern'l connection when flying int'l ticket |
Y |
Y |
Y (with up to 1 guest, except not in regional Koru Club) |
Y (& VS Clubhouses) |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y |
Y; US RCC/Club ONLY same day dom./ intern'l connection when flying int'l ticket |
Y; US RCC & Club ONLY same day dom./ intern'l connection when flying int'l ticket |
|
35K or 50 segments |
56K G/ 160K PL; |
50K (or 60 points-about 30 segments in higher fare classes, 60 segments in lower fare classes) |
50K Premium pts/no qualifying by segments starting 2008; Premium pts = base miles X COS X route multiplier |
57K (i.e. 3K plus Silver @ 16K plus 38K for Gold); 38K to requalify |
900 Q points; 800 for Australia / Norfolk Is.; 10% less to requalify |
Elite: 50K on |
50K Gold/ 100K Plat.; |
10K Starpoints / 50 JK flexible segments |
70K Q 12 mos to qualify; 70K Q calendar yr requalify |
50K in 1st year OR 80K over 2 years OR 40 TG int'l segments |
40K in 12 months; 30K/45K (Turkish residents) or 25K/37.5K (non Turkish residents) in 1/2 years to renew |
50K (or 60 segments ) |
PP 75K (or 90 segments); GP 50K (or 60 segments) |
% Bonus for Elite |
§0-50 on AC metal; 0-25 on LH, NH, BD; on base miles only |
25 G / 50 PL on CA flights |
100% on CO metal; 500 mile minimum |
100 on NH metal |
25 (all |
0 |
25 (only on SQ) |
2000 mi./10K Q & 50/100% Gold/Plat. only on SA metal |
15 (JK only) |
40% TAP |
0 |
100% Q miles on TK business; purchase up to 10K Q miles for 240 Euro |
100 (UA &. UA code share on LH, US & LH US-Europe) |
75 (PP)/50 (GP) on US, UA, NH |
+Special Bonus Miles |
gift or 25K^ at 150K Q; 40K^ @200K Q, 75K^ @250K Q, 150K^ @300K Q (see below!) |
0 |
50% Q miles on all Y and B econo fares on CO flights any fare; 250 Q mile min |
100% Q NH Japan domestic, 50% NH to China (after route multiplier applied) |
100% over 55K Q (note this means up to 625% total miles paid F after 55K Q!) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
5000 on qualifying/ requalifying |
0 |
0 |
0 |
+Upgrades- Domestic |
- see next: different choices available with varying NA, SWU & SSWU upgrades |
upgrades available for 3-7.5K miles (B, H, K and L class and higher fares) |
instant upgrades Y and B fares at time of ticketing; space available at 3 days for all other fares for member and companion; mileage based upgrades 5 15K miles |
20 upgrade points for qualify/requalify plus 2 for every 10K Q miles over 50K Q minimum qualify |
4 econo to bus UK/Europe |
N |
N |
same day airport 1 class upgrades available for 7K miles |
1 on birthday |
Y purchase for miles |
N |
purchase upgrades for miles |
500 mi NA -- 4 every 10K Q--confirm. 72 hr; can purchase upgrades for miles |
Unlimited N. Am./ Latin AM./ Carib., @ 4 (PP)/3 (GP) days prior / anytime full coach on US (Y,B,U)/HP (Y,H) |
+Upgrades- 1-class Int'l |
§6 SWU or 4 SWU/ 4 NA or 2 SSWU/ 2 SWU or 2 SSWU/ 4 NA on qualifying & 2 SWU @ 20, 40, 60, 90, 105, 135, 150K & every 30K after; 2 SSWU @ 75, 120, 165K & every 30K Q after; confirm at ticketing Y/M/U; 4 days other fares |
upgrades available for 6-20K miles (B, H, K and L class and higher fares) |
- instant upgrades Y and B fares at time of ticketing and space available at 3 days for all other fares for member and companion, all but longest haul flights |
- see above for earning; 4 points to upgrade domestic, 8 for int’l business and 15 for int’l first except China/Asia resorts=5 points business and 7 first |
N but can use domestic certs to upgrade to new econo |
2 segments/yr, confirm. 3 days, also good on reward travel; standby or higher cost at reservation one-way upgrades for points |
N |
same day airport 1 class upgrades available for 7500-45K miles |
N |
N |
Y (one 1 class RT upgrade on qual. or renewal; one 1 class RT upgrade @ 50K Q miles (annually); one sector upgrade awards for 16K-60K miles |
purchase upgrades for miles |
N; upgrades from select (non-deep discount) fares purchasable for 10K-60K miles --confirmable at time of reservation |
N |
Reward notes# |
blackouts; non-award Y inventory for up to 2X regular miles (member/ family) |
|
better Econo reward availability |
extensive reward list |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
no blackouts on standard awards |
no blackouts on standard awards |
Other Bonuses (all have priority check-in, waitlist, standby, baggage) (Star Gold members get at least 1 extra piece if piece concept applies or 20 kg if weight concept applies on any |
§ Choice of 2 of:
AND Choice of 2 of:
AND Choice of 1 of:
---------------------------
|
|
|
|
|
|
PPS:
plus for
|
Note: all Plat. benefits apply to Lifetime Plat. except:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Other Minuses |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
NOTES
Prepared by BlondeBomber from data supplied by Rudi, Catman, QuietLion, PremEx, auh2o, AnnaS, Celestar340, 3544quebec, Austman, Merry, Gekko, Koru Flyer, Dorian, Bernie, Curt, Gaucho100K, indogulf, ozstamps, LordLuck, craigm, Shareholder, james, paulo, UAL Traveler, miler, celbrian, peter42, Hagbard Viking, milehighj, guava, UALRSSRDTWRR, Nigel, pb9997, Patron, zaco, yvr-runner, ahrz, BrisbanePE, unixone, uli, cbellero, 1k-all-the-way, wingnut, Cloud Lounger, kempis, f4free, kawoh, Norway_Asia, g3space, bruin, Gustaf, Rojo, ackang, LH738, pt, CGK, Kiwi Flyer, mad_atta, flamboyant1, OSLflyer, Al B, Point_Chaser, Banton, PappaG, ntddevsys, fbessoles, stargold, RWY02KTM, dd, cedric, NihonNick, Andrew Yiu, jamespvg. Stranger., ACORD, HPtunco, demiurg, dia15222, Tante Kaethe, JeffISU, qasr, QF009, AndreasFromVienna, Zinzan, ulev, planeluvr, hclee01, zvezda, KenF, madman, totti, FCYTravis, edta450, beaubo, traveloguy, efrem, Chiangi, DownUnderFlyer, tnt537, Nick C, futaris, kiam
# see Hagbard Viking's Star Alliance Reward Comparison Chart for award comparability
* -- see 2005 Star Alliance Lounges for list of Star Gold lounges
** Minimum Miles/Earning - see Star Alliance Cross Earning Chart; all published fares eligible in most programs; (changing rapidly--check ff program websites for updates); Earn no miles for reward booking classes, e.g. O,I,X on most carriers D,W on AC and, in many programs, other than that airline's own ff program for the following fares:
!Non-mileage Threshold Gifts on AC Aeroplan-- 150K Q ($300 Fruits & Passion cert. OR 25K miles OR 2 nights at Starwood hotels OR 1 week AVIS full-size rental OR Maple Leaf Lounge membership for friend), 200K ($500 Roots cert OR Elite status for friend OR 40K miles OR 1 month AVIS full-size rental OR 3 nights at Starwood hotels), 250K ($2500 Harry Rosen OR Air Canada Vacations cert; OR 75K miles OR 8 flight North American Economy pass for two OR 2 months AVIS convertible rental for summer OR 4 nights at Starwood hotels), 300K Q miles ($4000 Air Canada Vacations cert; SE status for friend, OR 8 flight North American Executive Class pass for two OR 6 months AVIS full-size rental OR 5 nights at Starwood hotel OR 150K miles)
+Bonuses & Upgrades -- AC threshold bonuses & upgrade certificates awarded based on Q miles earned on all
flights; UA bonuses & upgrade certificates (except System Wide Upgrades) awarded based on Q miles earned on UA flights only (incl. UA codeshare on LH from N. America-Germany & LH transatlantic). One UA 1-way SWU upgrade origin-destination; UA mileage upgrades on paid higher coach International fares (Y,B,M ,H) & business class (C, D) & USA/Hawaii/Canada/Mexico/Central America in D,C,Y,B,M,H,Q,V,W,S,K,L,T. SWU Cert may also be used on same day one class standby basis on international LH metal flights for most paid booking classes.) SWUs are eligible for travel in Americas/Hawaii from all booking classes except Z & G, & elsewhere from all booking classes except Z, S, T, K, L & G. Complex rules--see http://www.united.com/page/article/0,6722,51127,00.html for latest.
§- Upgrades-One AC SWU or SSWU upgrade required origin-destination worldwide, including NA; NZ allows upgrades on any paid fare.
![]()